Religion and Dead Man Walking (1995)

One of the important aspects of Dead Man Walking (1995) was the depiction of religious concepts and symbols.  In the film, the viewer encounters Sister Helen Prejean, a more “modern” Catholic nun that does not wear the habit in a time after the Second Vatican Council.  Her dress is still conservative, yet does not necessarily distinguish herself as a Catholic nun.  As the film begins, it is interesting that Matthew Poncelet seeks the legal help of Sister Helen, rather than spiritual guidance.  However, Sister Helen accepts the challenge of helping Matthew both spiritually and legally, even though he has been convicted of rape and murder.

Image

Image 1: Sister Helen is screened at the jail security station (Time stamp 00:04::35).

Image

Image 2: Sister Helen meets Chaplain Farley for the first time (Time stamp 00:04::43).

After receiving Poncelet’s letter, Sister Helen arrives at the jail where he is being held.  She then encounters Chaplain Farley, who is a Catholic priest.  In these scenes, different crucifixes are displayed.  While arriving at the jail, Sister Helen is wearing a crucifix around her neck that symbolizes the death of Jesus Christ and his resurrection.  In Image 1, a security police officer at the jail wands over her crucifix, realizing this was the object that had triggered the metal detector to sound.  In Image 1, the crucifix and the metal detecting wand represent the merging of “church” and “state.”  The “church” aspect is represented in the religious crucifix, while the metal detecting wand represents the government and laws of the “state.”  The lines between the church and state become skewed in this film since Poncelet faces the death penalty.  As a Catholic nun, Sr. Helen fights for Poncelet’s right to live, even though she does not have the knowledge of whether or not he committed the crimes.  In contrast, Earl Delacroix, who identifies himself as a Catholic, experiences an internal, spiritual conflict as he seeks justice for his murdered son, Walter.

In Image 2, Sister Helen greets Father Farley, the Chaplain of the jail.  The background of the second image clearly displays two distinct crucifixes, one on the wall and another on a shelf.  However, the following discussion between Sr. Helen and Chaplain Farley is incredibly surprising.  Chaplain Farley is condescending towards Sr. Helen, asking her if she’s even been in a jail, and why she does not wear the habit.  After she coolly answers his questions, Chaplain Farley explains what he has heard about the Poncelet case.  Next, he bluntly asks Sr. Helen her motives by saying:

CHAPLAIN FARLEY: Do you know what you’re getting into?  So what is it, Sister?  Morbid fascination?  Bleeding-heart sympathy? 

SISTER HELEN: He wrote me and asked me to come.

CHAPLAIN FARLEY: Well there is no romance here, Sister.

In a way, Chaplain Farley seems to be insulting her motives.  As the above dialogue continues, Chaplain Farley appears to have little sympathy for Poncelet.  Their discourse is quite shocking since their work is guided by Christ’s sacrifice to spiritually help other individuals.  Even though the crucifixes visible in Image 1 and Image 2 are symbolically equivalent, Sr. Helen and Chaplain Farley’s attitudes towards Poncelet, and thus their ministries, are incredibly different.

Another religious concept displayed in this film is that of reconciliation.  In the Catholic Church, reconciliation is one of the seven Sacraments.  Other Sacraments include Baptism, Confirmation, and Matrimony.  Before he is executed, Matthew Poncelet confesses to Sr. Helen that he is guilty of killing Water Delacroix and raping Hope Percy.  While some may see his confession as a type of “reconciliation,” this would not be considered a valid Reconciliation in the Catholic Church.  A priest must be the individual to hear a sinner’s confession, while the sinner must also truly repent his or her sins.  Even though Poncelet admits his guilt and claims to be sorry for his crimes, the viewer will never know if he was truly remorseful.

 

-Paige T.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

2 responses to “Religion and Dead Man Walking (1995)

  1. Jason Jordan

    That’s an interesting point about Poncelet’s reconciliation. From his final words, I got the impression that he was truly remorseful in his crimes and think that the director used this moment to imply that he did. Since Sister Helen was Poncelet’s connection to religion, I think the implied message of the film is that he accepted responsibility. With this, it further complicates the death penalty issue on whether or not he should have been sentenced to death. And since he was truly sorry, this is what made the final, actual injection scene so powerful

  2. kayleigh0812

    I found your comment about church and state really interesting. I did not see it that way, but can make the connection. I think it is really interesting to see how the line of religion and the system do become skewed in this movie. I also agree that we will never know if Poncelet was ever remorseful. If he was remorseful I think that he should of had more actions that showed this remorse. A way to look at the remorse is also looking at the situation. Could he have just said this because of Sister Helen? It is difficult to tell whether a criminal is every remorseful or not.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s